Thief

[U4EA]

http://store.steampowered.com/app/239160/

[MKJ]

is getting terrible reviews. lol?

[U4EA]

Sad

But I'm going to try catching a few spoiler-free playthrough vids to see if I'd enjoy it, reviews aren't everything.

[MKJ]

that is true if they were talking about subjective issues.
broken AI, insultingly easy puzzles and a painful amount of loading screens are things you can't really ignore.

[U4EA]

TB's impressions. Haven't seen this yet, but he tends to be very critical when a poor game deserves it. Should be an interesting watch:

[youtube]xJS1yCSKlhs[/youtube]

[Whiskey 7]

Certainly looks an immersive (?) environment.

[Mogul]

I have watched a couple of reviews and read a couple, too. Honestly, the game looks pretty fun to me. Some of the reviews harp on things that I think are bizarre. The Kotaku review, over and over, bashed the game because when you entered a new area, the door behind you automatically closed. The environment and the gameplay (contextual control inconsistency notwithstanding) both continue to receive praise, so I am considering buying this. But hey, I like Final Fantasy IIjp and D3 (both of them you're thinking of) so my tastes are maybe a little weird.

[nbohr1more]

I you prefer the classic Thief 1 and 2 style play, there's always The Dark Mod:

http://www.thedarkmod.com

http://www.moddb.com/mods/the-dark-mod

It's now a standalone game. Doom 3 is no longer needed.

[SoM]

some like it some don't, get over it ppl